While real estate has long been a good, if slow, way to build wealth, it has one perennial issue. Good quality property is expensive.
Be it a commercial property in Gurgaon, a hospitality asset in Delhi-NCR, or a prime commercial property, these can easily run into crores of rupees.
This is where ideas such as fractional ownership in real estate come into play.
Fractional ownership lets multiple investors jointly invest in a property without each having to shell out a huge amount of money.
The basic workings are straightforward - participants will invest a certain amount in the property and get rights based on that investment.
There is, however, quite a bit more nuance involved in the process.
What is fractional ownership in real estate?
Fractional ownership is a way to own or get rights to a high-value property by having multiple people or entities share the investment required to buy it.
Say, for example, there is a commercial property worth ₹10 crore
Instead of one investor buying it, the investment can be split up into parts, with everyone getting a share in the property.
The participants in a fractional ownership structure do not necessarily have a right to a portion of the property itself; instead, their stake is generally in an SPV that owns the real estate. As such, this is a completely legal way to circumvent the need for a large initial investment to get into real estate, especially commercial and high-value residential real estate.
Now, let's move on to how it works
How Does Fractional Real Estate Ownership Work
The process of fractional ownership is slightly different in different SPVs, but the framework is more or less the same across most providers. Here's a brief look at how it generally works:
The SPV finds a property that meets certain criteria.
Generally, these will be commercial properties (hospitality, offices, warehouses, etc.) or income-generating assets (rental residential, commercial, healthcare, etc.). Sometimes, it can be something else as well.
The property goes through a due diligence process to make sure everything is in order, everything is properly documented, and that the projected rental income, if any, is plausible. Many factors go into this:
- Property details, ownership papers
- Tenancy - who are the tenants, what are the terms of the lease
- Location, rental yield, rental value
- Property valuation and projected yield
- Paperwork, legal documents, and legality of the transaction
- Property maintenance, management, and other expenses
- Exit route
This is arguably the most crucial step, as with fractional ownership in real estate, the risks are not mitigated completely. Instead, they are just spread out amongst many investors. This cannot be stressed enough.
3. The investors participate
The main investment opportunity is open for applications. The bulk of the money required to purchase the property is split between these investors.
The example above, with a ₹10 crore property, will likely not have ten investors each investing a crore. The total amount will range from a few crores to a few hundred crores, with investors putting in anywhere from ₹1 crore to even ₹1000!
This is, arguably, the most attractive part of the process, and the main draw for many investors. It does have its pitfalls as well, though.
4. The property is put in an SPV
The property that has been purchased through the collective efforts of the investors is placed in an SPV. Participants receive shares or a right to a fraction of this SPV.
That is why it is crucial to read the fine print before investing. You should know what precisely you own, and how you own it.
5. The property generates income
If there is a tenant in place, then the income from the property - after removing taxes, management fees, and other expenditures - gets distributed to the participants in the fractional ownership structure, based on their share in it.
This is a great way to participate in the rental yield from a high-value property, without having to host it yourself. Let's go over an example to further clarify this.
Fractional Ownership In Real Estate Example
Let us say there is a leased commercial property with a value of ₹100 crore
One hundred investors decide to go in on this property - each investing a sum of ₹1 crore.
Depending on the mechanics discussed earlier, the participants will have an economic interest in the property thus acquired. Assuming it is leased, the landlords and tenants will have a lease agreement in place that covers what the tenant can and cannot do, and how much they have to pay in rent.
This amount, after removing expenses, is then distributed amongst the tenants in the fractional ownership structure as a reward for their share. Keep in mind, however, that tenants in a fractional ownership structure are not necessarily entitled to the entirety of their rental payment, because a chunk of it has to be used to cover management and maintenance expenses. So it may only receive a portion of the total rental amount. That is why it is important to have a close look at the tenants in a property, as they have a direct impact on the yield.
Why Would People Buy Into A Fractional Ownership Structure?
As discussed earlier, the primary point of a fractional ownership is to be able to purchase and own a piece of a high-value property, without having to bear all the risks and responsibilities of doing so alone.
However, this is not the only advantage. There are a host of other benefits to investing with a structure such as this.
1. Access to commercial real estate
As previously discussed, commercial real estate has some considerable advantages over residential.
Fractional ownership allows one to purchase a piece of such a high-value asset, which would not be possible for an individual investor.
2. Rent yield
If the property in question is leased out, all of its tenants in a fractional ownership structure will be entitled to a share of it, depending on their ownership stake.
This will be a consistent yield, but it is important to remember that it is not guaranteed.
Vacancies, defaults, and other factors will affect the amount received by the participants.
3. Professional(property) management
Depending on the specific SPV, one or more parties may professionally manage the property in question.
This means that the responsibilities and headaches of property management fall on the lessors' shoulders, rather than one's own.
4. Diversification
Instead of tying up one's entire net worth in a single property and a single SPV, fractional ownership can allow one to participate in many properties, and possibly many SPVs as well. However, doing this will, of course, depend on one's investment amount and the minimum requirements set by each SPV.
All of these benefits combine to make fractional ownership an attractive opportunity. With that being said, these are also its drawbacks.
Is Fractional Ownership Any Different From Direct Property Purchase?
For our purposes, yes.
Buying a fractional share in a property is much like buying a piece of cake. One will not obtain full ownership of the property itself, but rather a stake in an SPV. Depending on the SPV, that can either mean shares or a stake in an investment product. Either way, before purchasing, one should always ask: what exactly am I buying here?
It is the SPV that determines one's risk exposure, ability to exit the deal, and other relevant considerations.
What Are Some Of The Drawbacks And Risks Of Fractional Ownership?
Unless the SPV has mitigated all the risks associated with the property and its performance, fractional ownership, just like buying a whole property, is an inherently risky enterprise.
There are many risk factors involved:
For example, if a property one has leased is completely vacant, or if rent has defaulted, or if the property is unable to yield returns comparable to the rate of inflation,
one may not be able to recoup their investment
It is not without its downsides.
Other things to consider when signing up for fractional ownership include:
- Exit strategy (liquidity risk) - There may be no buyers for your stake in the property. It is always important to have alternatives.
- Vacancies, defaults and other issues in lessees - Just because there is a leased tenant is no assurance that they will always stay there. They may default on the rent, or the vacancy may damage the reputation of the property and scare off future tenants.
That is why it is vital to perform some due diligence before investing.
Due Diligence Checklist For Fractional Ownership In Real Estate
A few things to consider when assessing a property are:
Who owns the property?
Make sure you identify the entity (SPV, REIT, trust, and so on). It's also vital to fully understand the nature of your interest.
Is the property leased?
If so, understand who the tenants are and how long the leases last. Know about any lock-in periods, annual escalation percentages and other details.
How is the income calculated?
Determine whether it is based on gross rent or projected distributable amount.
What are the overall costs?
Management, maintenance, and tax expenses, among others, must be taken into account.
Exit opportunity
This is possibly the single most important factor. There have to be buyers; otherwise, your investment will always remain a liability. Understand the options available.
It is also vital to assess the due diligence performed on the property.
Fractional Ownership In Real Estate Vs Direct Property Purchase
The essential difference between buying into a fractional ownership structure and buying property outright is simply one of degree. Whereas with an outright purchase, there is a lot more personal responsibility, risk exposure, and financial commitment, fractional ownership will reduce each of those commensurate with one's stake in the property (or the lack thereof). Neither will eliminate the risk factors associated with the purchase of a single property outright. In short, fractional ownership is a shared version of the risks, rewards, and responsibilities of direct property purchase.
Is Fractional Ownership Suitable For Everyone?
The short answer is no. It depends on the person in question.
Someone who looks to buy property as a high-yield quick investment may not be the best candidate for fractional ownership. Someone who desires greater liquidity may also not be the best candidate. That is why it is always critical to ask oneself: how does fractional ownership suit one's own investment goals, and what risks is one willing to take or not take?
In many ways, fractional ownership is like buying stocks. It can be more attractive, but if one doesn't understand the ins and outs, as well as the risks, it can quickly be turned into a nightmare of debt. So before signing up for something like that, it perhaps would be good to have a basic understanding of what one is doing.